Medical Technology
Medical Technology Has Advanced. Has the System Advanced With It?
When life-sustaining care cannot be reduced to a list of tasks.
I’ve been thinking about a conversation I had with Donna Patterson at the Ohio Department of Developmental Disabilities (DODD).
We were discussing advancements in medical technology and the increasing complexity of care for individuals receiving services.
Donna acknowledged those changes.
As I understood our conversation, one way the system is responding is by adding more tasks to the Nursing Task Inventory (NTI).
And I’ve been thinking about that ever since.
Because I have a question.
What happens when the medical technology isn’t simply a task?
What happens when the technology is part of an individual’s life-sustaining physiological system, requiring specialized knowledge, clinical judgment, equipment, troubleshooting, and emergency planning?
And what happens when the system responsible for coordinating services has known about those needs for years?
Let me explain using Alex’s NeuRx Diaphragm Pacing System.
A life-sustaining system, not a task
In January 2009, Alex became one of the youngest individuals to receive the NeuRx Diaphragm Pacing System, implanted by Dr. Raymond Onders in Cleveland.
That was nearly 18 years ago.
The system stimulates his diaphragm through surgically implanted components, allowing his diaphragm to contract and draw air into his lungs using negative-pressure breathing.
Alex’s diaphragm pacer is his primary respiratory life-support system.
His ventilator provides supplemental positive-pressure assistance.
His pacer is set at 16 breaths per minute, while his ventilator provides supplemental assistance with a backup rate set at 10 breaths per minute.
Those numbers do not describe two interchangeable systems.
You cannot simply turn off Alex’s pacer and assume his ventilator, at its current settings, will adequately replace it.
And that distinction matters enormously.
But let’s go deeper.
The NeuRx system includes external patient cables connecting to implanted components.
Its settings cannot simply be changed by a nurse, caregiver, local respiratory therapist, or emergency department physician.
Specialized programming equipment and expertise are required. For Alex, that expertise is with his diaphragm-pacing team in Cleveland.
And because of Alex’s catastrophic injuries at the cervicomedullary junction, his respiratory support exists within an extraordinarily complex neurological and autonomic system.
His responses to changes in breathing, ventilation, positioning, and other interventions can be highly individualized.
Changes in ventilation can affect carbon dioxide levels, blood chemistry, and physiological stability.
That isn’t something you capture by checking a box labeled respiratory care.
What happens when something goes wrong?
Recently, Alex and his nurse, Jenny, were troubleshooting an alarm from his diaphragm pacer.
Jenny noticed a kink in the patient cable.
They worked together, repositioned the equipment, and the alarm stopped.
The pacer was still functioning.
When I returned home, I replaced the cable with one of our backups because the alarm suggested the cable was beginning to fail.
I then walked Jenny through how to order a replacement.
That situation illustrates something important.
The task might be documented as monitoring equipment or responding to an alarm.
But what actually happened?
Jenny recognized a potential problem.
Alex participated in identifying and responding to it.
They understood that the pacer was still operating.
They knew when additional help would be needed.
I recognized the importance of replacing a potentially failing component before it became a more serious problem.
And we had a replacement cable available.
The safety of that situation depended on far more than the ability to perform a task.
It depended on familiarity, judgment, communication, equipment availability, and knowing the limits of what could safely be done.
Now imagine that same alarm occurring with someone unfamiliar with the NeuRx system.
Would they understand what the alarm meant?
Would they know whether the pacer was still functioning?
Would they know what to check?
Would they understand what not to change?
Would they know whom to contact?
Would they recognize when emergency stabilization was necessary?
Those are not hypothetical questions for someone whose breathing depends on this technology.
And if an internal component develops a problem, replacing an external cable may not solve it.
We cannot simply go to our local emergency department expecting specialized NeuRx repair.
A local emergency department can provide emergency medical stabilization, but the specialized device problem may require the Cleveland team.
So where is that complexity represented in an assessment?
A license is not the same as individualized competency
I’ve raised this concern repeatedly.
A licensed nurse may have extensive clinical experience without ever having encountered a diaphragm pacer.
The same can be true of respiratory therapists and physicians.
In fact, while contacting facilities that care for individuals using ventilators, I’ve encountered professionals unfamiliar with the NeuRx system.
That doesn’t necessarily make them poor professionals.
It means they may not possess the specific knowledge necessary to safely manage Alex’s respiratory care without additional training and support.
And that’s a critical distinction.
A license establishes professional qualifications. It does not automatically establish competency with every specialized medical technology or every individual who depends on it.
This is why I continue emphasizing the importance of individualized competency rather than simply documenting that a licensed professional is available.
Alex is cognitively intact.
He communicates.
He directs his own care.
He recognizes changes in his body that may not yet be apparent on a monitor.
His knowledge and participation are essential components of his care.
But his ability to direct his care does not eliminate his need for competent physical assistance.
The funding maze hasn’t disappeared
Now consider another piece of this situation.
We’re currently trying to obtain Medicaid coverage for replacement supplies for Alex’s NeuRx system.
Not a new pacer.
Not an experimental treatment.
Replacement batteries, patient cables, and connector holders for the life-sustaining system he’s depended on since 2009.
Previously, some of these supplies were reimbursed through local county funds.
Those funds are no longer available.
So now we’re navigating the Medicaid process, determining the appropriate billing pathway, locating a supplier willing and able to submit the claim, and obtaining medical-necessity documentation.
During this process, we were sent a medical-necessity form intended for ventilators.
But we’re not requesting a ventilator.
We’re requesting supplies for Alex’s diaphragm pacer.
That’s why I’ve been working with his pulmonologist, Dr. Kirkby, who understands Alex’s specialized respiratory needs and has already documented the role of the pacer in his care.
Again, the distinction matters.
Getting paperwork completed is not the same as getting the medical reality accurately documented.
And a system that recognizes a piece of equipment as essential still needs a practical way to maintain that equipment.
Authorized doesn’t mean delivered
The same disconnect exists with staffing.
Alex’s nurse has authorization for up to 40 hours per week.
But the hours she can actually provide are generally closer to 20–25.
The authorization exists.
The need exists.
The full amount of nursing support is not consistently available.
Meanwhile, our family continues filling the gaps.
And Alex remains stable much of the time.
But here’s something I wish more people understood.
Stability does not prove that the level of support is unnecessary.
Sometimes stability is the result of extraordinary effort, constant observation, preparation, problem-solving, and intervention.
If an assessment measures only what is visibly happening, without understanding what is preventing a crisis, it risks drawing the wrong conclusion.
Low utilization does not necessarily mean low need.
And a family successfully preventing emergencies should not become the justification for overlooking the supports required to prevent them.
What does Ohio law say?
This is where the conversation becomes bigger than Alex.
Ohio Revised Code § 5126.15 establishes responsibilities for county-board service and support administration, including assessing needs, developing individual service plans, coordinating services, and monitoring their implementation.
Ohio Administrative Code 5123-4-02 addresses individualized assessment, risks, planning, service coordination, and monitoring.
Ohio Revised Code § 5123.62 establishes rights of individuals with developmental disabilities, including rights relating to appropriate medical care, treatment, and participation in decisions affecting their lives.
And § 5123.64 provides mechanisms for reporting and seeking enforcement of alleged rights violations.
These laws don’t automatically mean that an agency must directly purchase every device component or that every unresolved need constitutes a legal violation.
Different agencies have different authorities.
But they raise important questions.
When an agency knows about a significant health-and-safety risk, what is its responsibility to respond?
Who is responsible for coordinating the solution?
Who follows up when the first proposed solution doesn’t work?
Who ensures that a plan is actually implemented?
And what happens when the individual and family continue carrying the unresolved risk?
Documenting a risk is not the same as addressing it.
What is the assessment actually measuring?
Ohio is moving toward greater use of standardized assessments, including interRAI, to understand individuals’ needs and inform future support planning.
Standardized tools can provide useful information.
And adding tasks to the NTI may help capture activities that previously went undocumented.
But I keep returning to the same concern.
Can a standardized, task-based structure adequately measure individualized complexity?
Can it recognize the difference between performing a task and understanding the clinical consequences of that task?
Can it measure the expertise required to troubleshoot a specialized life-sustaining device?
Can it distinguish an individual who cannot physically perform care from someone who is fully capable of directing that care?
Can it recognize the work families perform to prevent emergencies?
Can it account for services that are authorized but unavailable?
And can it recognize when an individual’s medical reality falls outside the assumptions built into the assessment?
I am not arguing that assessments have no value.
I’m asking whether the system has adequate safeguards when the assessment doesn’t capture the whole person.
Because people should not have to fit the limitations of an assessment.
The assessment should be capable of recognizing the reality of the person.
So what’s the plan?
Alex has had his diaphragm pacer since January 2009.
Nearly 18 years.
Medical technology has continued advancing.
Care has become increasingly complex.
Yet many of the challenges surrounding Alex’s technology remain remarkably similar to those we encountered in the beginning.
Finding knowledgeable providers.
Ensuring appropriate emergency planning.
Obtaining specialized supplies.
Navigating different agencies and funding sources.
Explaining the same medical distinctions again and again.
And in some ways, those challenges have become harder.
I appreciate the people within these systems who are genuinely trying to help.
But individual efforts cannot substitute for a sustainable structure.
So I keep coming back to one question.
What is the plan?
Not just another task added to an inventory.
Not another box checked.
Not another authorization that cannot be fully staffed.
Not another referral that leaves the individual and family to figure out the next step.
An actual, individualized, sustainable plan.
One that recognizes the technology.
Understands the person.
Includes competent support.
Provides for essential equipment and supplies.
Accounts for emergencies.
And respects the individual’s right to direct their own life.
Because Alex isn’t a collection of nursing tasks.
He’s a person.
A person whose life has been sustained through extraordinary medical technology, remarkable clinical care, years of learning, and an enormous amount of individualized problem-solving.
He wants to live his life.
Not simply exist within the limits of a system.
Medical technology has advanced. The complexity of care has advanced. But if the system’s response is primarily to add more tasks to an assessment, has the system truly advanced with the people it is supposed to support?
After nearly 18 years, I think that’s a fair question.
And I think it deserves an answer.
The Goal Is Life. ❤️
Relevant Ohio provisions: ORC §§ 5126.15, 5123.62, 5123.64; OAC 5123-4-02.
#TheGoalIsLife #DisabilityRights #HCBS #ComplexCare #DiaphragmPacing #NeuRx #PatientSafety #MedicalTechnology #CaregiverAdvocacy #IndependentLiving


Comments